Recommended by:


Chicago Tribune

Winning Orders: The big cheeses of Chicago Pizza
Thick Pizza
Piero's 335 Ridge Ro. Wilmette, Cash or local checks. 251-5550.
This was essentially a tie, with Gino's East: earning two-lengths of a point more in the third and most critical round

 

Chicago Sun-Times
Ilana Platt, Highland Park

Piero's Pizza, 335 Ridge Rd. Wilmette (251-5550), is mainly a takeout place, but it has a couple of seats if you're desperate. It is the best pizza anywhere. The crust is perfect, as are the sauce and the cheese.

 

North Shore Magazine
Sherman Kaplan

The stuff of which pizza is made.
Piero's Pizza 335 Ridge Rd. Wilmette, makes the best stuffed pizza on the North Shore, at unusually reasonable cost. Although it's primarily a carryout place, it is the place my family turns to most when I'm not reviewing and the craving for pizza strikes.

 

New Trier News
Emily Levy

So where do you find the "perfect pizza"? A poll taken among a group of sophomores and juniors ranked the six most popular pizza places on the North Shore. Piero's, Lou Malnati's, Carmen's, Gino's East, Dominoes, and Homemade Pizza Company were all ranked according to the following criteria: taste, price, and convenience.

Though it was a very close call, the majority of students voted Piero's Pizza as the best overall pizza...
...When asked why their pizza earned top rank, Piero's claimed that they met all the criteria… plus more. "Our pizzas are tasty, inexpensive, and convenient," says a Piero's spokesman.

"People want pizza that gets there fast, and that's what we are all about." Charging only $8.75 for the perfect balance of cheese and tomato sauce, Piero's pizza is definitely money well spent. Piero's is at 335 Ridge in Wilmette...
...The New Trier student body has spoken. Piero's is officially the best pizza on the North Shore.

http://www.PierosPizza.com